Choose a degree if you want an academic qualification and can prove the money for a student visa; choose an Ausbildung (vocational training) if you want to earn from the first month and can get an employer's training contract. The Ausbildung is the faster way to a paid position, the degree the more flexible one, and after either you can stay in Germany to look for work and later settle. This page compares the two as ways of moving to Germany; it does not explain how to find a training place.
- AusbildungBerufsausbildung
- Vocational training in Germany. In the usual dual form you work in a company under a training contract, are paid a training allowance (Ausbildungsvergütung) and attend a vocational school alongside. It ends with an exam and a recognised qualification. The residence permit for it is § 16a of the Residence Act.
"Ausbildung" is mostly a job-seeker's word in search results, which is why most pages about it list vacancies. This one answers a different question: if you are choosing between training and study as the reason to move, what does each ask of you, what does each pay, and where does each lead? For the study side in detail see the German student visa and bachelor's degrees in Germany.
Ausbildung and university side by side
| Ausbildung (§ 16a) | University degree (§ 16b) | |
|---|---|---|
| What you need first | A signed training contract with a company entitled to train; the Federal Employment Agency's consent is part of the procedure | An admission from a university, or acceptance to a Studienkolleg |
| German level | Law sets none; as a rule A2, and B1 for a qualified training, decided by the mission or immigration office | Set by the programme: for German-taught degrees DAAD Türkiye gives B2 to C1; English-taught programmes ask for an English test instead |
| Money while you do it | You are paid: at least €724 per month gross in the first year, rising each year | No tuition at most public universities, but you pay semester fees and your living costs |
| Money the visa expects | €959 per month is the amount the statute treats as a secured livelihood for a training permit | €992 per month, usually shown as €11,904 per year in a blocked account |
| Work on the side | Up to 20 hours a week, no self-employment | 140 days a year working days a year |
| Length | Several years; the statutory minimum pay is set for up to the fourth training year | six, seven or eight semesters for a bachelor's, two, three or four semesters for a master's |
| After you finish | Job-search permit of up to 18 months, then a skilled-worker permit | Job-search permit of up to 18 months, then a skilled-worker or Blue Card permit |
Entry requirements and German level
For a degree
A Turkish lise graduate applying to a German bachelor's programme needs, according to DAAD Türkiye, placement in a four-year, face-to-face bachelor's programme through the YKS; the same page names no Studienkolleg or foundation-year route for lise graduates, and applicants with an international school diploma such as the IB, Matura or Abitur need no YKS result. A German-taught degree asks for German at B2 to C1, an English-taught one for an English certificate. How the Turkish diploma is assessed is explained in the Turkish diploma guide, and foundation years covers the preparatory routes in other countries.
For an Ausbildung
Vocational-training law sets no language level. The Federal Employment Agency's instructions (December 2024) say that as a rule A2 will be needed to start any training and B1 for a qualified training, meaning one of at least two years, and that the missions or immigration offices decide. Under § 16a Abs. 3 the office asks for proof of German only where the training school has not tested your language and no preparatory German course is planned; the permit also covers a preparatory German course for a qualified training. Plan on needing working German; the rules above are built around it.
The other entry condition is not about you but about the employer. The Federal Employment Agency has to consent to the permit, it checks the signed training contract, and it checks that the company is entitled to train (the instructions describe the ratio of skilled staff to trainees it looks at). Contracts are therefore commonly signed on condition that the permit is granted. A diploma is not a legal condition of the training permit itself; companies set their own selection criteria, which this page does not cover.
Pay during training against the cost of study
The core financial difference is direction: an Ausbildung pays you, a degree costs you. The statutory minimum for a training that starts in 2026 is €724 per month gross a month in the first year, €854 per month in the second, €977 per month in the third and €1,014 per month in the fourth (BIBB). The year in which the training starts fixes the rate, and BIBB adjusts the first-year amount every year. Firms bound by a collective agreement may pay under the minimum if that agreement says so, and most pay above it: BIBB calculates an average of €1,133 per month gross across all training years in firms bound by collective agreements in 2024. That average is an orientation, not a promise: the occupation and the region move it considerably.
A student pays no tuition at most public universities: DAAD says there are generally no fees for bachelor's courses or most master's courses at state institutions, with the semester contribution (€70 to €430 according to DAAD, often including a transport ticket) due every term. The exceptions matter. Baden-Württemberg charges non-EU students €1,500 per semester, and in Bavaria DAAD says fees for non-EU students can reach several thousand euros per semester depending on the degree, each institution deciding for itself. DAAD estimates living costs at €900 to €1,200 a month, mostly rent. The tuition-fees guide lists the exceptions; tuition-free universities in Europe gives the wider picture.
In practice a first year looks very different. The student has the money shown in the account (€11,904 per year for twelve months) available and no salary unless they find a job within the work allowance. The trainee has a salary from the first month and no tuition, but is tied to one employer and one occupation for the length of the contract. The first-year budget puts figures on both cases, and the blocked-account guide explains how the study amount is proved.
The visa for each route
Both routes start with a national visa from a German mission, followed by a residence permit in Germany. The legal basis, the money and the work rules differ, as the table shows.
| Point | Training permit (§ 16a) | Student permit (§ 16b) |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | Mission or immigration office, after the Federal Employment Agency's consent | Mission or immigration office, on the university's admission |
| Livelihood amount | €959 per month (statute's deemed amount for training) | €992 per month |
| Work allowed | 20 hours a week independent of the training; no self-employment | 140 days a year working days a year (Arbeitstagekonto) |
| Preparation counted | A preparatory German course for a qualified training | A Studienkolleg or a preparatory language course tied to an admission |
| Typical validity | For the training | 2 years at first issue and on extension |
If you do not yet have either a contract or an admission, the search permits in § 17 give up to 9 months: one to look for a training place, one to apply for a study place, both with work of 20 hours a week. As a rule they can be changed only into a training or study permit, or in a few other cases (§ 17 Abs. 3), so they are not a way to stay for another purpose. The applicant-visa guide covers the study side, and the language-course route compares the pre-admission options.
What each route leads to afterwards
The law treats the two similarly after completion. A person who completes a qualified vocational training in Germany is entitled to a residence permit to look for work (§ 20 Abs. 1 Nr. 3); a person who completes a degree is granted one under Nr. 1. Both run up to 18 months and require a secured livelihood. The job then has to be one the skilled-worker titles allow: § 18a gives a permit for any qualified job to a skilled worker with vocational training, § 18b the same for a skilled worker with an academic degree.
| Step | After an Ausbildung | After a degree |
|---|---|---|
| Search for a job | Up to 18 months (§ 20) | Up to 18 months (§ 20) |
| Work permit | Skilled-worker permit, § 18a | Skilled-worker permit, § 18b, or EU Blue Card with a salary of at least €50,700 per year in 2026 |
| Settlement permit | 2 years with the permit and 24 months of pension contributions, because the training was completed in Germany (§ 18c) | The same shortened route for a domestic degree; a Blue Card holder with basic German qualifies after 27 months, or 21 months with B1 |
| Without the German qualification | 3 years as a skilled worker | 3 years as a skilled worker |
Two further details. Time spent lawfully in Germany for study or vocational training counts half towards the years of holding a permit for the general settlement permit (§ 9 Abs. 4), so the years of training or study are not wasted on that route. And the degree route has one extra door: the Blue Card, which has its own thresholds, also at a reduced level of €45,934.20 per year for some occupations and for degrees no more than 3 years old, with the Federal Employment Agency's consent. The statute does not rank the two routes by salary; what you earn depends on the occupation. The post-study permit and the EU Blue Card are explained in the Germany guide, from student to resident compares the countries.
Who each route suits
These are judgements from the rules above, not predictions about any one person.
- The degree suits you if you have a place or a realistic chance of one, you want an academic qualification, you can show the study amount for the visa, or you want the Blue Card route, and you can wait for the first salary until after graduation or a student job.
- The Ausbildung suits you if you want to be paid from the start, you prefer learning an occupation by doing it, you can reach the German level, and an employer is ready to sign the contract.
- A mixed path is possible only in steps. A completed training or a first degree does not close the other door, but each step needs its own permit and its own conditions; ask the immigration office before you plan the switch.
Who this choice does not suit
The Ausbildung does not suit you if you cannot get a contract: without one there is no training permit, and the only alternative is the search permit, which has an age limit and a money requirement of its own. It also does not suit you if you cannot work in German by the start. The degree does not suit you if the funds are not there: the study visa wants the money available in advance, and Baden-Württemberg and Bavaria can add tuition on top. If you are over 30 or have a family, both routes work differently; see moving after 30 and moving with a family. And if neither route fits, the overview of ways to move to Germany lists the others.
Next step on Scholway
- Study side: the German student visa and German and English language requirements.
- Money: the first-year budget and the blocked account.
- Pre-admission options: the language-course route.
- Afterwards: the 18-month job-search permit and permanent residence.
- Choosing a degree: colleges in Germany and German universities.
Frequently asked questions
What is an Ausbildung?
An Ausbildung is vocational training in Germany: in the usual dual form you work in a company on a training contract, receive a training allowance and attend a vocational school, ending with an exam and a recognised qualification. The residence permit for it is § 16a of the Residence Act and needs the Federal Employment Agency's consent.
Is Ausbildung better than university in Germany?
Neither is better in general. An Ausbildung pays from the first month (€724 per month gross at least for a 2026 start) but needs a contract and German at the level the office sets; a degree has no tuition at most public universities but needs a university place and €992 per month for the visa. Both lead to a job-search permit of up to 18 months.
What German level do I need for an Ausbildung?
Vocational-training law sets no level. The Federal Employment Agency's instructions say that as a rule A2 is needed for any training and B1 for a qualified training of at least two years, and that the missions or immigration offices decide. Proof is not requested where the training school tests the language or a preparatory German course is planned.
Can I work while doing an Ausbildung on a visa?
Yes, up to 20 hours a week in a job independent of the training (§ 16a Abs. 3), without separate approval, but not as self-employed. A student permit instead allows 140 days a year working days a year.
Can I stay in Germany after finishing an Ausbildung?
Yes. After a qualified training completed in Germany you are entitled to a permit of up to 18 months to look for work, provided your livelihood is secured. With a qualified job you then move to a skilled-worker permit (§ 18a), and because the training was completed in Germany a settlement permit can follow after 2 years with 24 months of pension contributions.
Do I need a university degree to do an Ausbildung in Germany?
No. The training permit in § 16a has no degree requirement, and vocational-training law sets none either; employers set their own selection criteria. The separate permit to search for a training place does ask for a school-leaving qualification that gives access to higher education, in Germany or in the country where it was earned.
Sources
18 sources, all official
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 16a Berufsausbildung; berufliche WeiterbildungBundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 16b StudiumBundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 17 Suche eines Ausbildungs- oder StudienplatzesBundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 20 Arbeitsplatzsuche im Anschluss an Aufenthalte im BundesgebietBundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 18a Fachkräfte mit BerufsausbildungBundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 18b Fachkräfte mit akademischer AusbildungBundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 18c Niederlassungserlaubnis für FachkräfteBundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 18g Blaue Karte EUBundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 9 Niederlassungserlaubnis (Abs. 4 Nr. 3: half credit for study and vocational-training time)Bundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Aufenthaltsgesetz § 2 Begriffsbestimmungen (Abs. 3 secured livelihood; Abs. 9 to 12a language levels)Bundesministerium der Justiz / gesetze-im-internet.de (Official)
- Bekanntmachung zu § 2 Absatz 3 des Aufenthaltsgesetzes über den Mindestbetrag zur Sicherung des Lebensunterhalts (für das Jahr 2026), vom 13. August 2025, BAnz AT 29.08.2025 B1Bundesministerium des Innern / Bundesanzeiger (Official)
- Bekanntmachung zu § 18g des Aufenthaltsgesetzes über die Mindestgehälter für die Blaue Karte EU (für 2026), vom 2. Dezember 2025, BAnz AT 18.12.2025 B3Bundesministerium des Innern / Bundesanzeiger (Official)
- Mindestausbildungsvergütung steigt 2026 auf 724 Euro (Pressemitteilung 28/2025, 13.10.2025)Bundesinstitut für Berufsbildung (BIBB) (Official)
- Fachliche Weisungen Aufenthaltsgesetz und Beschäftigungsverordnung (Stand 12/2024), § 16a AufenthG / § 8 BeschVBundesagentur für Arbeit (Official)
- Almanya'da yükseköğrenim (lisans ve master başvurusu)DAAD Türkiye (Official)
- Costs of education and living (tuition fees, semester contribution, living costs)DAAD (Official)
- Tuition fees for international students (Baden-Württemberg)Ministerium für Wissenschaft, Forschung und Kunst Baden-Württemberg (Official)
- Musterrechtsverordnung gemäß Artikel 4 Absätze 1–4 Studienakkreditierungsstaatsvertrag (§ 3 Studienstruktur und Studiendauer)Kultusministerkonferenz (KMK) (Official)